In the aftermath of Hurricane Helene, which left thousands of western North Carolina residents without power and running water, a contentious debate has begun over a proposed 42% hike in homeowner insurance premiums across the state. The North Carolina Rate Bureau, which represents insurance companies, has submitted a staggering 2,000-page proposal outlining rate increases ranging from 4% in some mountain regions to a whopping 99% in coastal areas. Cities like Raleigh, Charlotte, and Greensboro are facing proposed increases of around 40%, while 11 western counties devastated by Helene are looking at a 20.5% hike.
The Rate Bureau argues that the increases are necessary due to skyrocketing inflation, particularly in building materials, and the growing frequency and severity of catastrophic storms. Attorney Mickey Spivey pointed to Helene’s unprecedented destruction in western North Carolina and the devastating impact of Hurricane Florence in 2018, which resulted in billions of dollars in damages.
However, the Insurance Department’s attorney, Terence Friedman, countered that the industry’s methods for calculating rate increases are flawed and ignore state law requirements. He claimed that the department’s actuaries will present alternative rates that will allow insurance companies to earn a fair profit while keeping premiums affordable for homeowners.
As the hearing continues, the fate of homeowner insurance rates hangs in the balance. If the proposed increases are approved, many homeowners may face unaffordable premium hikes, forcing them to seek coverage through a “consent to rate” exception, which could lead to even higher rates. On the other hand, if the rates are deemed excessive, insurance companies may be forced to reevaluate their business models and potentially stop issuing policies altogether.
The outcome of this hearing will have far-reaching implications for homeowners across North Carolina, and its timing couldn’t be more critical, with early voting set to begin on October 17. As the state grapples with the challenges of climate change and increasingly frequent natural disasters, one thing is clear: the stakes have never been higher for homeowners and the insurance industry alike.
Leave a Reply