The Housing Market’s Catch-22: Low Rates vs. High Anxiety
Jerome Powell and the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) have a tough balancing act to perform, regardless of market or consumer sentiment. Unfortunately, their rates strategy has thrown a wrench into the property sector’s gears.
Rate Volatility Paralyzes Market Movement
A recent report by global real estate consultants Knight Frank reveals that consumers are holding onto properties purchased at lower mortgage rates, rather than buying new ones at higher rates. This stalemate is attributed to rate volatility and economic uncertainty. The FOMC may argue that they only set short-term rates, but the reality is that long-term mortgage rates tend to follow suit.
The Mortgage Rate Rollercoaster
Before the pandemic, homebuyers enjoyed an extended period of incredibly low mortgage rates. However, since early 2022, when the Fed began hiking rates to combat inflation, mortgage rates have skyrocketed to around 6%. In contrast, they were as low as 2.6% in early 2021. This drastic change is squeezing buyers across the board, with those owing large sums to the bank facing potentially thousands of dollars in increased monthly payments.
Fear and Uncertainty Grip the Market
The unwinding of the yen carry trade, sparked by base rate moves in the U.S. and Japan, has left investors questioning the Federal Reserve’s assessment of the global economy’s fragility and the risk of domestic recession. Economists’ reactions vary widely, with some calling for emergency rate cuts and others advocating for a 25 basis point reduction.
Unlocking the Housing Market
According to Knight Frank, the key to unlocking the housing market lies in addressing the reluctance of homeowners to part with mortgages agreed upon during the era of ultralow rates. National market data shows that turnover in the first eight months of the year hit a 30-year low.
Luxury Markets Feel the Pinch
The trend is particularly pronounced in luxury markets, where elevated borrowing costs have weighed on activity. Prime buyers, with wealth tied up in other asset classes, are also feeling the uncertainty caused by higher rates and the November election.
A Frenzied Boom Unlikely
Despite the Fed’s unexpected 50 basis point cut in September, mortgage rates remain double what they were before the pandemic. As Jonathan Miller, CEO of Miller Samuel, notes, this context is crucial for understanding why the property sector can’t expect a “frenzied boom” as rates begin to come down.
Homeowners Feel Backed into a Corner
The problem is not limited to the luxury end of the property sector. Homeowners across the spectrum are feeling trapped by interest rates. A report by Edelman Financial Engines found that over one-third of homeowners feel “stuck” in their current home due to rates, with nearly half of those under 50 saying they cannot move up the property ladder because of mortgage offers.
Widespread Anxiety
The report also revealed that nearly three-quarters of respondents are worried about rates, with four out of 10 people willing to move to another state to save money. As the housing market struggles to find its footing, one thing is clear: Jerome Powell and the FOMC have a delicate balancing act to perform to restore confidence and movement in the property sector.
Leave a Reply